Share:
Motor Addicts is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and the Amazon.ca Associates Program. We may earn a commission when you buy through Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
Short answer: If you live where winter means packed snow, ice and weeks below freezing (most of Quebec, Northern Ontario, the Prairies, BC’s mountain routes), buy dedicated winter tires. If you drive mostly in a city that gets mixed winters, plows quickly and you want one set of tires all year, an all-weather tire with the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol is a reasonable compromise. A plain all-season tire is the weakest choice for a Canadian winter. Two money traps to know: Manitoba’s winter tire loan stopped covering all-weather tires on October 1, 2026, and in Ontario no insurer page we checked says all-weather tires qualify for the winter tire discount, so ask before you assume.
“All-weather” sounds like it should mean “good in every weather”. It does not quite. It is a tire category that sits between an all-season tire and a dedicated winter tire, and in Canada the difference matters for your safety, your insurance and, in two provinces, the law. This guide sets out what each type is, how to read the sidewall, what Quebec, B.C., Ontario and Manitoba actually say, and how to decide.
How we put this together: we have not track-tested these tires. Everything below comes from Transport Canada, provincial governments, Manitoba Public Insurance, the Tire and Rubber Association of Canada (TRAC), insurers’ own pages and the tire makers’ own Canadian or North American product pages, all read in October 2026. Sources are listed at the end. Where an official source does not answer a question, we say so.
All-season vs all-weather vs winter tires at a glance
| Type | Sidewall symbol | Use it for | Weak spot |
|---|---|---|---|
| All-season | Usually M+S only (some carry the snowflake) | Spring to fall; mild winters if paired with winter tires | Transport Canada says all-season tires lose elasticity and grip below 7 °C |
| All-weather | Three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF) plus M+S | One set all year in mixed, mostly urban winters | Makers themselves say dedicated winter tires are better on ice and in severe winter |
| Winter | 3PMSF (some also carry an ice grip symbol) | Roughly November to April anywhere with real winter | Soft compound wears fast in summer heat, so you need a second set |
Read the sidewall first: 3PMSF vs M+S
The three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF). Transport Canada describes this symbol as the mark of a tire that meets specific snow traction performance requirements and is designed for severe snow. TRAC explains that to carry it, a tire has to pass a standardized traction test on medium-packed snow (ASTM F1805), with Transport Canada setting the minimum performance threshold. TRAC also notes a newer ice grip symbol, introduced in 2022, for tires that pass an ISO test on ice.
M+S (mud and snow). This is not a winter rating. Continental’s Canadian guide points out that M+S is based on tread geometry and no performance test is required to use it. Plenty of all-season tires, including many SUV and light-truck tires, carry M+S and nothing else.
Where all-weather fits. All-weather tires carry the 3PMSF symbol, so on paper they meet the same snow traction minimum as a winter tire. B.C.’s government tire page lists all-weather tires among 3PMSF tires. The catch is that the symbol tests snow traction; it does not promise winter-tire grip on glare ice or in deep cold.
One naming wrinkle: Michelin calls its CrossClimate2 an “all-season” tire, yet lists it as 3PMSF certified, and Goodyear tags its Assurance WeatherReady 2 with the symbol as well. In practice, go by the symbol on the sidewall, not the word in the ad.
What the law says, province by province
Quebec: winter tires required December 1 to March 15
Quebec requires winter tires on Quebec-registered passenger vehicles, including rentals, from December 1 to March 15. A compliant tire has to show the winter pictogram (the mountain-and-snowflake symbol) or be studded. The government page does not mention all-weather tires by name, but because the test is the pictogram, an all-weather tire that carries the 3PMSF symbol meets the rule. Studded tires are allowed from October 15 to May 1 on passenger vehicles. Quebec’s legal minimum tread is 1.6 mm, and it recommends 4.8 mm or more in winter. The fine for driving without winter tires during the period is $200 to $300.
British Columbia: signed highways, October 1 to April 30
On signed B.C. routes, a legal winter tire is marked either M+S (the legal minimum) or 3PMSF, with at least 3.5 mm of tread, fitted at least on the drive axle as a matching pair. The province recommends 3PMSF for cold weather and lists all-weather tires among them. The requirement runs October 1 to April 30 on signed routes; on some highways outside mountain passes and high-snowfall areas it ends March 31. Roadside signs and the province’s route map tell you which roads are covered. Studded tires are allowed October 1 to April 30.
Ontario: no mandate, but a discount and stud rules
Ontario does not require winter tires. Studded tires are allowed in Northern Ontario on vehicles registered there, and not in Southern Ontario except for visitors from other provinces and Northern Ontario residents. Ontario’s winter driving page says the easiest way to identify a severe-snow tire is the 3PMSF symbol, that winter tires can shorten braking by up to 25%, and that all-season tires can start to lose grip at 7 °C.
Manitoba: the loan program no longer covers all-weather tires
Manitoba Public Insurance’s Winter Tire Program lends up to $2,000 per vehicle at prime plus 2% for tires, rims, mounting, balancing, alignment, TPMS sensors and studding. Tires have always needed the 3PMSF symbol. Since October 1, 2026, they must also be designed and marketed for winter only: tires sold as all-weather, all-season, four-season or year-round are no longer eligible, even with the symbol. If you are in Manitoba and planning to finance tires this fall, buy dedicated winter tires.
For winter tire rules in the other provinces, including studded tire dates, see our best winter tires in Canada guide, which has a table for all ten provinces.
Do all-weather tires get the Ontario winter tire insurance discount?
Ontario’s insurance regulator, FSRA, says all insurers must offer a discount if you install winter tires, and tells drivers to ask their insurer how to qualify. Neither FSRA nor ontario.ca defines what counts as a winter tire for the discount, and neither mentions all-weather tires. So the answer depends on your insurer’s own rules. Here is what the insurers’ own pages said when we checked in October 2026:
| Insurer | Discount stated | Tires | Dates |
|---|---|---|---|
| CAA (South Central Ontario) | 5% of the auto premium | Four tires meeting “the winter tire designation”; underwriting rules apply | On by November 20, kept on until at least April 15 |
| Sonnet | Not stated | A full set of true winter tires with the mountain-snowflake logo | Says insurers usually want them on November 1 to April 1; you tick a box on your policy |
| TD Insurance | Not stated (offered in Ontario and Newfoundland) | Four winter tires; all-weather not listed as qualifying | December to March |
| belairdirect | Up to 5% in Ontario | Not specified | Not specified |
| The Co-operators | Up to 5%, varies by province | Not specified | Not specified |
None of these pages says all-weather tires qualify, and TD’s page lists winter tires only. Several insurers (Intact, Desjardins and Aviva among them) did not publish discount terms on the pages we found. Before you buy all-weather tires partly to save on insurance, ask your insurer or broker in writing whether that exact tire qualifies and what dates apply.
Which should you buy? Our take
The honest answer is that the 3PMSF symbol sets a floor, not a ceiling. Michelin’s Canadian FAQ recommends dedicated winter tires for the best performance in extreme winter conditions, including ice, even for its own 3PMSF CrossClimate2. Nokian, which sells both, says dedicated winter tires are still superior in severe, icy conditions and that all-weather tires are not meant to replace them in the harshest environments. TD Insurance says the same about extreme cold. When the companies selling all-weather tires tell you this, believe them.
Buy dedicated winter tires if
- You live in Quebec, Northern Ontario, the Prairies, the B.C. Interior or anywhere roads stay snow-packed or icy for weeks.
- You drive rural roads, hills or highways before the plows get there, or you commute at night and early morning when black ice forms.
- You are in Manitoba and want the MPI loan, or your Ontario insurer only gives the discount for winter tires.
- You have a performance car or a rear-drive car. Summer performance tires and a cold Canadian morning are a bad mix, and a proper winter set on a second set of wheels makes the swap cheap and quick.
An all-weather tire makes sense if
- You drive mostly in a city that plows and salts quickly, such as Toronto, Vancouver, Victoria or Halifax, and you can stay home on the worst days.
- You have nowhere to store a second set and do not want to pay for storage and two swaps a year.
- You put on low annual mileage, so a single set will not wear out early from year-round use.
- You would otherwise drive on all-season tires all winter. Compared with that, an all-weather tire with the 3PMSF symbol is a clear step up.
What we would avoid is the middle road many drivers take: all-season tires all year, in a province with real winter. TRAC’s 2025 survey found that 77% of Ontario drivers already use winter tires, and among drivers outside Quebec who do not, three in four said all-season tires are good enough. Transport Canada and TRAC both say all-season tires lose grip below 7 °C, which covers most of a Canadian winter.
All-weather tires you will see in Canadian shops
These are how the makers themselves describe the tires on their own Canadian or North American pages. We have not tested them and are not ranking them; the list is here so you can recognise the names and check the sidewall symbol.
- Nokian Remedy WRG5: sold as a year-round all-weather tire with 3PMSF, marked “officially approved for winter use”, and a snowflake wear indicator in the tread that disappears when winter grip is worn.
- Toyo Celsius II: an all-weather touring tire with the 3PMSF symbol.
- Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive: all-weather, 3PMSF rated.
- Michelin CrossClimate2: Michelin calls it all-season, but it carries 3PMSF. Michelin says North America keeps the CrossClimate2 for the next several years, while the CrossClimate3 launched in Europe in 2025.
- Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2: sold as an all-season commuter tire, tagged 3PMSF.
- Hankook Kinergy 4S2: pitched as one tire for every weather; Hankook’s U.S. page lists 3PMSF and M+S on all sizes.
- Bridgestone WeatherPeak and Firestone WeatherGrip: all-weather touring tires. Their Canadian pages did not state the 3PMSF symbol when we checked, so confirm it on the sidewall before you buy.
If you go the dedicated winter route instead, our winter tire picks for 2026 cover the Michelin X-Ice Snow+, Bridgestone Blizzak, Nokian Hakkapeliitta and budget options.
When to switch, and how much tread is enough
- Timing: Transport Canada’s rule of thumb is temperature, not a date: below 7 °C, all-season and summer tires lose traction. Most insurers that give a discount also set their own dates (CAA SCO wants winter tires on by November 20).
- Tread: Transport Canada advises against using tires worn close to 4 mm on snow-covered roads. B.C. requires 3.5 mm on its winter routes, and Quebec recommends 4.8 mm or more. A cheap tread depth gauge settles the question in seconds.
- Fit four: Transport Canada says to install a full set of four of the same type, size, speed rating and load index, not two.
- Pressure: cold air lowers tire pressure, so check it more often once temperatures drop, using the pressure on your door-jamb placard.
A small tire-care kit for the season
Whichever tire you choose, these inexpensive tools make it easier to stay on top of tread and pressure through the winter:
- Tire tread depth gauge to check you are above 4 mm before the snow: Amazon.ca | Amazon.com
- Digital tire pressure gauge for quick cold-morning checks: Amazon.ca | Amazon.com
- Portable tire inflator to top up at home instead of at a frozen gas-station hose: Amazon.ca | Amazon.com
- Tire storage bags if you run two sets and store the off-season tires yourself: Amazon.ca | Amazon.com
We do not list prices because they change daily; check the current price on Amazon. For the rest of your winter prep, see our winter car emergency kit checklist.
FAQ
Are all-weather tires the same as winter tires?
No. Both carry the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol, so both meet the minimum snow traction test. But all-weather tires are built to be used all year, and makers including Michelin and Nokian say dedicated winter tires perform better on ice and in severe winter conditions.
Are all-weather tires legal in Quebec in winter?
Quebec requires tires showing the winter pictogram, the mountain-and-snowflake symbol, from December 1 to March 15. The government page does not name all-weather tires, but an all-weather tire carrying that symbol meets the stated requirement.
Do all-weather tires count as winter tires in B.C.?
Yes. On signed B.C. routes a tire marked M+S or with the 3PMSF symbol, with at least 3.5 mm of tread, is legal, and the province lists all-weather tires among 3PMSF tires.
Do all-weather tires qualify for the Ontario winter tire insurance discount?
It depends on the insurer. FSRA says insurers must offer a winter tire discount but does not define a qualifying tire. None of the insurer pages we checked says all-weather tires qualify, and TD lists winter tires only, so confirm with your insurer before you buy.
Can I use the Manitoba MPI winter tire loan for all-weather tires?
Not any more. Since October 1, 2026, MPI only finances tires designed and marketed for winter. Tires sold as all-weather, all-season, four-season or year-round are not eligible, even with the 3PMSF symbol.
When should I put winter tires on in Canada?
Transport Canada uses temperature as the guide: below 7 °C, all-season and summer tires lose grip. Check your insurer’s dates too if you claim a discount; CAA South Central Ontario, for example, wants winter tires on by November 20.
How much tread do winter or all-weather tires need?
Transport Canada advises not using tires worn close to 4 mm on snow-covered roads. B.C. requires at least 3.5 mm on its winter routes, and Quebec recommends 4.8 mm or more in winter.
Is M+S the same as a winter tire rating?
No. M+S (mud and snow) is based on tread design and no performance test is required. Only the three-peak mountain snowflake symbol shows a tire passed a snow traction test.
Sources
- Transport Canada, Using winter tires
- Tire and Rubber Association of Canada, Winter Tire Report 2025
- Gouvernement du Québec, Winter tires
- Government of B.C., About winter tires and Winter driving
- Government of Ontario, Winter driving
- FSRA, How to save on auto insurance
- Manitoba Public Insurance, Winter Tire Program
- CAA South Central Ontario, Winter tire discount; Sonnet, Winter tire savings in Ontario; TD Insurance, Winter vs all-season tires; belairdirect, Winter tires 101; The Co-operators, Are winter tires worth it?
- Continental Canada, Winter tire markings
- Maker pages: Michelin CrossClimate2, Nokian Remedy WRG5, Nokian on all-weather vs winter, Toyo Celsius II, Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActive, Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady 2, Hankook Kinergy 4S2
You're in. Check your inbox — a welcome email is on its way.
Share:










